RRIF Withdrawal Guide for Seniors with Million-Dollar Assets

Ask MoneySense

I have invested well and now I am in my 80s. My RRIF is almost $3 million and is going to attract heavy taxes. My other investments are about $2 million, some with capital gains which we are going to donate to charity.

Any suggestions on how to reduce the huge tax liability? Should we incorporate?

—Amy

RRIF withdrawals and estate planning for seniors with large investment portfolios

A large Registered Retirement Income Fund (RRIF) creates a substantial deferred tax obligation. While having significant savings is a good problem to have, many seniors worry about minimizing taxes so they can preserve more for their estate or intended beneficiaries.

RRIF withdrawals are fully taxable and are added to your annual income. You can transfer a RRIF to a spouse on a tax-deferred basis, but a single or widowed account holder with a very large RRIF may face tax rates topping 50%. When a RRIF holder dies, the plan is generally taxed as if the full balance were withdrawn on the date of death, which can trigger a very large tax bill for the estate.

What is the minimum RRIF withdrawal?

Federal rules require a minimum annual withdrawal from a RRIF. For seniors in their 80s, minimum withdrawal percentages typically fall roughly between 7% and 11% of the RRIF balance. For Amy’s nearly $3 million RRIF, that translates to approximately $200,000 to $300,000 withdrawn each year. Those amounts will likely push taxable income into the top marginal tax bracket, limiting opportunities to take additional income at lower rates.

RRIF withdrawals: Which tax strategy is best?

Withdrawing extra funds from a RRIF while you are already in the top tax bracket rarely improves your after-tax outcome. Consider a simple illustration: if you withdraw an extra $100,000 and pay a 50% marginal tax, you are left with $50,000 to invest in a taxable account. If that money grows at 5% annually for 10 years, it becomes roughly $81,445.

If instead you leave that $100,000 in the RRIF for 10 years at the same 5% return, it grows to about $162,890. Even after a 50% tax on withdrawal at that later date, you would have the same $81,445. This comparison ignores tax-treatment differences—investment returns inside a RRIF compound tax-deferred, while returns in a taxable account are reduced by taxes each year—so generally keeping funds in the RRIF produces a better long-term result.

Because you don’t need extra cash flow, the most efficient approach for preserving your estate may be to limit RRIF withdrawals to the minimum required amount and accept the deferred tax liability, rather than accelerating withdrawals and realizing immediate high taxes.

Should you donate your investments to charity?

Donating appreciated non-registered securities to a registered charity can deliver two tax benefits. First, you receive a charitable donation receipt for the fair market value of the donated securities, which can create a meaningful tax credit—often worth about 50% of the donation for high-income taxpayers. Second, donating the securities avoids the capital gains tax that would otherwise result from selling them.

For example, donating $100,000 of securities with an adjusted cost base (ACB) of $50,000 produces a $100,000 donation receipt. The charitable tax credit might save roughly $50,000 in tax, and avoiding tax on the $50,000 capital gain could save another roughly $12,500, for combined tax savings in this example of about $62,500. Keep in mind, however, you have given away $100,000 in market value, so the net out-of-pocket effect is still about $37,500 in this scenario.

Is incorporating the answer to your tax concerns?

Incorporating an operating business can provide substantial tax deferral benefits for active business income, and selling shares of a qualified small business corporation can produce tax savings in certain situations. However, incorporating an investment portfolio by itself generally does not solve the RRIF tax issue.

High-net-worth investors sometimes use holding companies when they have an active incorporated business. Business income retained in a corporation can benefit from lower small business tax rates and be moved into a holding company on a tax-deferred basis, helping to keep investment assets separate from the operating company. But this structure is tied to active business income and specific tax rules; it is not a straightforward solution for converting a personal RRIF into a tax-advantaged corporate asset.

Other tax-saving opportunities

There may be other ways to reduce your family’s overall tax burden. Lifetime gifts to children or grandchildren can shift income to family members in lower tax brackets and help them maximize their tax-sheltered accounts. Gifting while you are alive can also reduce probate and estate administration costs and lets you enjoy seeing relatives benefit from your generosity.

Another consideration is helping family members with high-cost borrowing or assisting them to pay down high-interest debt. By reallocating wealth within the family, you might achieve better after-tax outcomes for the household as a whole, though any gifting strategy should be considered against your own cash-flow needs and long-term plans.

How to handle taxes on RRIF withdrawals

In summary, there is no simple way to eliminate the significant tax associated with a very large RRIF. You can either accept high taxes on larger withdrawals during your lifetime or face a potentially large tax bill for your estate at death. Donating appreciated securities to charity can produce meaningful tax savings and is an effective option if you want to support charities, but it does involve transferring value away from your estate. Incorporation is unlikely to help with a RRIF held personally. Exploring lifetime gifts and income-splitting options within the family can provide both tax and non-financial benefits and may be worth discussing with a trusted tax advisor or estate planner.