Moving to the U.S.? How to Access Your Locked-In RRSP

For Canadians who move to the United States, a common concern is what can be done with a locked-in RRSP—often called a Locked‑In Retirement Account (LIRA). These accounts are intended to preserve pension savings for retirement, but under certain circumstances leaving Canada can open a path to access those funds earlier than expected. The rules are statutory, vary by jurisdiction, and are not uniform across the country.

Locked-in retirement accounts (LIRAs) generally result when an employee transfers the commuted value from a workplace pension—either defined benefit or defined contribution—into an individual account. Unlike a standard RRSP, a LIRA is governed by pension standards legislation in the jurisdiction where the original pension plan was registered, rather than solely by the Income Tax Act. That legislative framework is designed to ensure pension assets are available for retirement and not withdrawn prematurely.

Why locked-in accounts exist

The fundamental purpose of locked-in accounts is to protect retirement income. When funds move from an employer-sponsored plan into an individual account, pension rules typically restrict access. At retirement, the money is usually converted into a Life Income Fund (LIF) or a comparable vehicle, which enforces minimum and maximum annual withdrawal limits to preserve income over the retiree’s lifetime.

Does leaving Canada change the rules?

Moving to the U.S. does not automatically unlock a LIRA. However, many federal and provincial pension statutes include a provision that permits unlocking after a sustained period of non-residency. In several jurisdictions, an individual who has been a non-resident for at least 24 consecutive months may apply to withdraw locked-in funds. That 24‑month clock generally begins when Canadian tax residency ends, not merely when a person physically relocates.

Applicants seeking to unlock funds must submit formal proof of non-residency. Commonly required documents include Canada Revenue Agency records, statutory declarations, and any forms required by the pension authority that governs the original plan. Each pension regulator has its own administrative process and evidentiary standards.

Related reading: Moving abroad? Think about the tax consequences

Not all jurisdictions allow non-resident unlocking. The availability depends entirely on which pension statute governs the account. Some federal and provincial regimes permit unlocking after long-term non-residency, while others are more restrictive. For example, Québec’s pension rules do not include a general non-resident unlocking provision.

Jurisdiction matters

Locked-in accounts are controlled by the pension legislation of the jurisdiction where the original employer’s pension plan was registered. That might be the federal regime or the laws of a specific province such as Ontario, British Columbia, or Alberta. Differences between jurisdictions tend to be procedural—varying wait periods, documentation rules, unlocking options and administrative steps—rather than conceptual, but those procedural differences can materially affect access.

The tax implications

Eligibility to unlock a LIRA is only one part of the decision. The tax consequences in Canada and the U.S. often determine whether unlocking makes financial sense.

For Canadian tax purposes, lump-sum withdrawals by non-residents are generally subject to a 25% withholding tax at source. The Canada–U.S. tax treaty can reduce withholding on certain periodic pension payments to 15%, but lump-sum withdrawals from Canadian registered plans typically remain subject to the higher 25% withholding rate.

In the United States, withdrawals from Canadian registered retirement plans are usually taxed as ordinary income. Canadian withholding tax can generally be claimed as a foreign tax credit on a U.S. return, which helps avoid double taxation, but the credit may not fully offset U.S. tax liability if the taxpayer’s U.S. marginal rate is higher. The final tax cost depends on the taxpayer’s marginal rates, exchange rates at the time of withdrawal, state tax rules, and overall income for the year.

Consider a simplified example
Imagine Dean permanently moves to the U.S. and qualifies to unlock a $100,000 CAD LIRA. If he withdraws the full amount as a lump sum, Canada withholds 25%—$25,000—and he receives $75,000 CAD. For U.S. tax reporting the gross withdrawal is converted to U.S. dollars; if the exchange rate is 1.35 CAD per USD, the $100,000 CAD equals roughly $74,000 USD of taxable income. If Dean’s U.S. federal marginal tax rate is 32%, his rough U.S. tax on the income would be about $23,700 USD before foreign tax credits. He can typically claim a credit for Canadian tax paid (converted to USD), but if his combined U.S. federal and state tax rate exceeds the effective Canadian withholding, he may still owe additional U.S. tax. Exchange rates, state taxes, and total annual income all affect the outcome.

Sometimes waiting makes sense

For many Canadians living in the U.S., leaving a LIRA untouched can be the smarter strategy. If current U.S. income places them in a high marginal tax bracket, if exchange rates are unfavorable, or if future retirement plans allow for more efficient tax treatment of periodic withdrawals, delaying access may reduce overall taxes. Cross-border financial planning often comes down to timing and coordination of tax treatment across both countries.

The bottom line

A locked-in RRSP isn’t necessarily inaccessible after emigrating. Sustained non-residency can, in many cases, open a route to withdraw funds, but the decision requires careful navigation of three different frameworks: the pension statute that governs the account, Canadian non-resident tax rules, and U.S. tax law. Before acting, determine which jurisdiction governs the account and assess the cross-border tax consequences to avoid unintended tax costs and ensure the most efficient outcome.

Newsletter

Get free MoneySense financial tips, news & advice in your inbox.

subscribe now