Gold Investment Alternatives for Canadians Beyond Bullion

Gold prices have surged. As of October 17, the spot price of gold stood at CA$5,928 per ounce—about US$4,227—driven by what market commentators call the “debasement trade.” In short, investors are responding to long-term macroeconomic pressures: prolonged loose monetary policy, rising U.S. debt, and the gradual erosion of purchasing power in many paper currencies. When fiat money can be expanded with few limits, non-debasable hard assets like gold frequently regain attention as stores of value.

Scenes of long lines at gold dealers have returned in many cities, including in Canada. As early as September 2023, outlets reported cases where one-ounce gold bars sold out within hours of being listed online, a sign of renewed retail demand.

Before succumbing to fear of missing out, however, it’s worth weighing alternatives to owning physical bullion. Beyond the investment case, several practical considerations make direct ownership of coins or bars less convenient or cost-effective for many investors.

The case against bullion

This is not a dismissal of owning physical gold—there is an undeniable appeal to holding a Gold Maple Leaf or similar coin. The tactile experience and historical symbolism are powerful. But objectively, buying and storing physical bullion carries costs and frictions that can reduce your effective returns.

One major factor is the bid-ask spread. Dealers rarely transact at the spot price you see quoted online. They earn a margin between the price they sell at and the price they will buy back. For example, on October 17 Vancouver Bullion & Currency Exchange (VBCE) listed one-ounce Gold Maple Leaf coins with:

VBCE Buy: CA$5,893
VBCE Sell: CA$6,068

That spread—CA$175, roughly 3%—means the market price must rise by at least that amount for you to break even, before accounting for storage and security costs.

Security is another consideration. Many owners invest in heavy, bolted, fireproof safes at significant expense. Storing bullion in a safety deposit box at a bank reduces some personal security concerns but reintroduces counterparty risk and incurs annual fees. The appeal of gold for some investors is its potential to sit outside financial intermediaries; once it’s locked in a bank vault, that advantage is diminished.

If physical possession is your priority, buy bullion and accept these trade-offs. If instead your goal is portfolio diversification or exposure to gold’s price movement, there are alternatives that remove many of the hassles associated with hands-on ownership. Exchange-traded funds (ETFs), closed-end funds (CEFs), and gold mining equities each offer different balances of cost, liquidity, and operational complexity.

Rankings

The best ETFs in Canada

read now

Gold ETFs

Gold exchange-traded funds (ETFs) typically hold custodied, audited bullion and are structured to allow in-kind creations and redemptions by authorized participants. That arbitrage process helps keep an ETF’s market price close to its net asset value (NAV), limiting persistent premiums or discounts and improving liquidity.

Key considerations when selecting a gold ETF are low management expense ratios (MERs) and tight bid-ask spreads, as both impact long-term returns. A prominent Canadian example is the BMO Gold Bullion ETF (ZGLD), which has a competitive 0.23% MER and stores unencumbered 400-ounce bars in a local, audited vault. For investors seeking a low-cost, liquid way to track the spot price of gold, well-constructed ETFs are often the simplest solution.

Gold CEFs

Closed-end funds (CEFs) predate ETFs as a vehicle for gold exposure. A CEF issues a fixed number of shares at its initial public offering, and thereafter shares trade only in the open market. This fixed supply can cause market prices to trade at a discount or premium to NAV depending on supply and demand.

Although less popular than ETFs, CEFs persist because some longstanding funds remain relevant in the precious metals space. The Sprott Physical Gold Trust (PHYS) is a well-known CEF example, carrying a 0.39% MER and trading at a modest discount to NAV (2.29% at the cited date). Buying a CEF at a discount can be attractive, but there is no guarantee that the discount will narrow. Investors who follow CEFs closely often use statistical measures—such as z-scores comparing current discounts to historical norms—to assess relative value.

Gold miners and streamers

Although Canada sold its official gold reserves in 2016, the country remains a major global producer, offering indirect exposure to gold through domestic mining stocks. Large producers such as Barrick Gold and Agnico Eagle Mines operate diversified portfolios that expose shareholders to operational leverage: as gold prices rise, revenues increase while many fixed costs remain stable, magnifying profit growth; the reverse occurs when prices fall.

Mining companies face operational, geopolitical, and commodity-specific risks. Many pay dividends, which can provide income that bullion and most ETFs/CEFs lack. Streaming and royalty companies—examples include Franco‑Nevada and Wheaton Precious Metals—take a different approach: they provide upfront capital to producers in exchange for a portion of future output at discounted prices. That model often yields steadier cash flows and lower capital intensity, making these firms generally less sensitive to short-term spot-price swings than traditional miners.

Be mindful of overlap if you already own a broad Canadian equity ETF tracking the S&P/TSX Capped Composite Index or a similar benchmark: the materials sector, which includes miners, can represent a meaningful share of those indexes and add concentration risk if you layer on additional gold exposure.

Junior exploration companies—often called junior miners—are typically speculative, reliant on outside financing, and highly volatile. Their stocks can behave like biotech plays: large swings tied to exploration results and commodity sentiment. For most long-term investors, these firms are better avoided or limited to a small, speculative allocation.

An oddball gold security

Canadian Gold Reserves (MNT) is an exchange-traded receipt (ETR) that sits between the ETF and CEF structures. It carries a 0.35% sponsor fee and is backed by the Government of Canada, with the Royal Canadian Mint serving as custodian. The Mint stores bullion in secure facilities and assumes liability for loss or damage except under extraordinary circumstances. MNT holders can also redeem shares for physical gold on a monthly basis.

For investors who prioritize government backing, direct redemption rights, and custody by the Mint, MNT can be appealing. However, its bid-ask spread tends to be wider than that of some ETFs and CEFs, making it less suitable for active traders or short-term allocations.

The acid test

If you remain bullish on gold despite its recent rally and strong retail interest, and if physical bullion isn’t a good fit, the main alternatives are ETFs, CEFs/ETRs, and equities—miners, streamers, and royalty companies. Each option carries trade-offs in cost, liquidity, leverage to the metal, and operational risk.

Deciding which path to take depends on your goals: do you want pure price exposure, government-backed custody and redemption rights, or equity-linked upside with potential dividends? Keep expectations realistic. Gold can serve as an effective hedge and store of value, but it is not a universal solution to market volatility or currency depreciation. Understand the costs—spreads, fees, and storage—and choose the vehicle that best aligns with your objectives and risk tolerance.

Newsletter

Get free MoneySense financial tips, news & advice in your inbox.

subscribe now