Compare Ontario High-Risk Auto Insurance Quotes

Auto insurance is mandatory for drivers in Canada, and premiums can vary dramatically. Why the wide range? Insurers price policies based on risk. They assess the vehicle (is it prone to damage, theft, or mechanical failure?), the area where the car is kept (urban neighbourhoods typically show higher theft and collision rates than rural ones), and—above all—your personal driving risk. The Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario (FSRAO), which oversees property and casualty insurance in the province, notes that insurers primarily set rates according to how likely they believe a driver is to file a claim. If an insurer views you as particularly risky, you may be steered to a high-risk driver insurance policy that costs substantially more than standard coverage.

Below is a practical guide to understanding high-risk driver insurance in Ontario: what makes a driver high risk, where to find coverage, how Facility Association fits in, why honesty matters on applications, and steps you can take to lower premiums over time.

Are you a high-risk driver?

You may be labelled high risk if you’ve been at fault in multiple collisions, have a serious conviction such as impaired driving, or have accumulated many minor convictions and traffic tickets. Non-payment of premiums that leads to policy cancellation can also trigger high-risk status. When insurers see a pattern that suggests a higher probability of claims or missed payments, they often increase rates dramatically or decline coverage.

Ontario’s FSRAO emphasizes that while insurers can charge more, “the insurance industry as a whole cannot refuse to sell you basic insurance.” That protection exists so eligible drivers can obtain at least minimum coverage, but it comes at a price: high-risk auto insurance premiums may be thousands of dollars higher than average. For context, the FSRAO reported an average premium of $2,006 as of October 2024; high-risk policies often exceed that by a substantial margin.

Resource highlight

Compare car insurance quotes and save

In under five minutes, compare personalized auto insurance quotes from Canada’s leading providers.

compare now
Powered by ratehub.ca

What are your options for high-risk driver insurance in Ontario?

Being considered high risk doesn’t mean you’ll be uninsured. Start by contacting your current insurer—some companies will continue coverage but at a higher premium. If your current insurer can’t accommodate you, look to insurers that specialize in high-risk drivers; several Ontario-based providers focus on this market and can offer tailored policies.

Using an auto insurance comparison tool can speed up research and help you evaluate multiple quotes at once. Comparing quotes will clarify differences in premiums, deductibles, and coverage options so you can choose a policy that balances cost and protection.

What is Facility Association?

If specialty insurers won’t provide coverage, your final recourse in Canada may be Facility Association. Facility Association is a not-for-profit organization made up of member insurers that operates in Ontario and several other provinces and territories. Membership is mandatory for insurers that sell auto insurance in those jurisdictions, and Facility Association exists to ensure that drivers who cannot obtain coverage through the standard market still have access to basic insurance.

Insurance arranged through Facility Association is underwritten and administered by member companies; the association itself simply coordinates placement for higher-risk drivers who cannot find coverage elsewhere.

Why honesty is the best option for auto insurance

It can be tempting to omit or misrepresent information on an application to secure a lower premium, but that’s a risky move. If an insurer discovers false or missing information, it may cancel your policy or refuse a claim. Insurers commonly verify details by requesting a driving abstract from Ontario’s Ministry of Transportation, which shows collisions, demerit points, convictions, licence suspensions, and other relevant history.

Be transparent when you apply for coverage. Full disclosure protects you from denied claims and policy cancellations down the road.

How to lower your auto insurance premium

Being labelled a high-risk driver makes lower premiums more challenging, but there are practical steps you can take to reduce costs and improve your standing over time:

Pay premiums on time to avoid cancellations and additional penalties.
Consider a higher deductible to lower your annual premium if you can afford larger out-of-pocket expenses after a claim.
Purchase only the coverage you truly need—avoid optional add-ons that don’t match your circumstances.
Reduce annual mileage and notify your insurer of significant decreases in driving; lower use can translate into lower risk and lower premiums.

Arguably the most effective strategy for reducing rates over the long term is to rebuild a clean driving record. Many negative marks are temporary. For example, certain demerit points in Ontario are removed two years after the offence. By committing to safe, defensive driving and avoiding tickets and convictions, you can gradually restore your profile and access more competitive rates in the standard insurance market.