Wealthsimple, Canada’s largest and most aggressive fintech challenger to the big banks, has steadily introduced new features over the past year designed to give individual investors access to tools once reserved for institutions or high-net-worth clients.
In December 2025, I examined one of those launches — physical gold trading — and concluded that the answer depends on your goals. For broad diversification, gold funds remain the more efficient choice. But if owning physical gold matters to you, paying a fee to have it delivered can be a sensible option.
Wealthsimple’s innovation has continued. One of its more recent additions is direct indexing, a trend that has gained traction in the United States, especially in advisor-managed accounts. Direct indexing lets investors replicate an index by holding the individual securities directly, rather than through an exchange-traded fund (ETF).
Until recently in Canada, direct indexing was largely out of reach for everyday investors, which makes its arrival on a retail-focused platform notable. Alongside gold and direct indexing, Wealthsimple now offers access to private equity, private credit, cryptocurrency, and portfolio lines of credit.
But greater access raises a key question: just because you can use these strategies, should you? Below is a clear explanation of Wealthsimple’s direct indexing, how it works, the benefits, and the important caveats to consider before adding it to your portfolio.
What is direct indexing?
An index is a set of rules that determines which securities belong in a group and how much weight each receives; it is not a tradable asset on its own. To invest in an index, you normally buy an index ETF or mutual fund. The fund provider pools capital from many investors and purchases the underlying securities; you then own units that represent a proportional stake in those holdings.
Direct indexing takes a different approach. Instead of pooling money with other investors inside a fund, your account holds the individual stocks directly. A provider uses technology to build and maintain a basket of securities in your account that mirrors a chosen index.
The investor experience is still largely hands-off: you do not manually buy hundreds of stocks. You entrust your capital to the provider, in this case Wealthsimple, and their system handles the trading, rebalancing, and ongoing management.
Wealthsimple’s offering is based on the Morningstar US Target Market Exposure Index and the Morningstar Canada Domestic Index. While the names differ, the result is similar: broad exposure to U.S. and Canadian equity markets through direct ownership of individual securities rather than through a fund.
The benefits of direct indexing
Direct indexing is primarily aimed at investors using a non-registered, taxable brokerage account. Wealthsimple’s direct indexing is not available in registered accounts such as a tax-free savings account (TFSA), a registered retirement savings plan (RRSP), or a first home savings account (FHSA). The main advantage of direct indexing is tax-loss harvesting, which only applies in taxable accounts.
In Canada, selling a security for less than its purchase price produces a capital loss. Capital losses can offset capital gains, lowering tax liabilities. If you do not have gains in the current year, losses can be carried back up to three years or carried forward indefinitely. Over time, systematic harvesting of losses can meaningfully improve after-tax returns.
The superficial loss rule is an important limitation: if you sell a security at a loss and then repurchase the same or a substantially identical security within 30 days before or after the sale, the Canada Revenue Agency denies the loss for tax purposes. Tax-loss harvesting works around this by replacing the sold security with a similar, but not identical, holding to maintain market exposure without triggering the rule. For example, selling BCE and replacing it with Telus preserves telecom exposure while avoiding a superficial loss; in the U.S., selling Visa and buying Mastercard follows the same idea.
Direct indexing applies this concept at scale. Within a broad index there are always winners and losers. Even when the overall portfolio is up, many individual stocks may still trade below their purchase price. Direct indexing platforms can systematically identify those positions, sell them to realize losses, and reinvest the proceeds into similar securities that maintain overall exposure. This can be repeated throughout the year to create a steady stream of realized losses to offset gains elsewhere. Wealthsimple calls this potential benefit “tax alpha,” estimating it could add roughly 0.5% in additional after-tax return over time.
The fine print you need to watch out for
Tax-loss harvesting is a practice experienced advisors have used for years in discretionary accounts. Wealthsimple is effectively making that institutional practice available to retail investors, but the offering still carries nuances and trade-offs to understand before committing.
One feature Wealthsimple highlights is customization: investors can exclude individual companies from the index for personal reasons. If you don’t want exposure to a particular stock or to an entire sector, you can remove those holdings. That flexibility is attractive, but it also introduces discretion. Indexing works because it is rules-based and comprehensive; once you start excluding holdings, you invite tinkering, which can introduce tracking error and quietly undermine long-term outcomes.
Another consideration is currency. Wealthsimple does not currently offer U.S. dollar accounts for direct indexing, so Canadian investors must convert Canadian dollars into U.S. dollars. Wealthsimple applies a reduced corporate FX spread of 0.05%, lower than its standard rate, but it is still a cost — approximately $5 on a $10,000 investment. Beyond the initial conversion, U.S. dividends paid in dollars are converted back into Canadian dollars at a higher 0.4% rate and may be converted again if reinvested. Repeated conversions create a small but persistent drag over time.
How returns are presented also matters. Wealthsimple notes that the Morningstar US Target Market Exposure Index delivered a 14.3% average annual return over the past 10 years. While that performance is factual for that period, the past decade has been an unusually strong stretch for large-cap U.S. equities. A longer-term view of the broader U.S. market, using an ETF proxy with data back to 1993, shows a nearer 10.5% annualized return. A 14% annualized return is possible over certain periods, but it is not a baseline expectation.
Finally, direct indexing is not the only way to harvest tax losses. You can perform tax-loss harvesting with low-cost ETFs, though with fewer individual positions to work with. For instance, if a broadly held U.S. ETF is below your cost basis, you could sell it to realize a loss and replace it with another broadly similar ETF that provides comparable exposure without being identical. Direct indexing scales that process across hundreds of securities, which is the advantage, but the underlying concept is not brand new and can sometimes be replicated with simpler, lower-cost approaches.
The final word on direct indexing
More choice for Canadian investors is positive when offerings have transparent pricing and low minimums. Wealthsimple’s direct indexing is competitive on those fronts: a 0.15% annual fee in line with many index ETFs and a $1,000 minimum that lowers the barrier to entry. Operationally, reporting is straightforward, with transactions appearing on a T5008 slip suitable for CRA autofill.
That said, the practical audience for direct indexing is smaller than it might appear. Many Canadians still have room to contribute to tax-advantaged registered accounts. Between TFSA room accumulated over time, the FHSA lifetime limit, and RRSP contribution room — plus registered education savings plans for families and workplace pension plans — a large portion of investors’ savings can and often should be sheltered in registered accounts first. Because tax-loss harvesting only applies to taxable accounts, direct indexing is less relevant for investors who have not yet maximized their registered-account contributions.
In practice, direct indexing is a more niche solution. It may suit investors who have already maxed out registered accounts, regularly invest in taxable accounts, and are comfortable with a fully equity-based portfolio. For that group, the tax-loss harvesting potential may justify the added complexity. For most investors, simpler approaches using low-cost ETFs inside registered accounts are likely to remain the more practical and cost-effective path.
Read more about investing strategies:
- The best GIC rates in Canada for 2026
- Pitfalls to avoid when investing in sector ETFs
- Advice on portfolio strategy amid geopolitical market volatility
- Perspective on the Bitcoin bear market and where we stand