Inheriting a Cottage: Capital Gains Tax Implications

Leaving a cottage to family

I’m sorry for your loss, Jill. Below I’ll outline the main legal and tax considerations to keep in mind when a cottage has been left to family members and the deed is currently in one person’s name.

The fact the deed is in your name only suggests the property was either held solely by you or held jointly with your husband with a right of survivorship. If it was joint with right of survivorship, the cottage would have passed directly to you at the time of his death and therefore outside the terms of his will. That matters because ownership rules like joint tenancy can override instructions in a will.

Ask a Planner: Leave your question for Jason Heath »

Are there capital gains on inheriting a cottage?

When an asset passes to a surviving spouse on death, Canadian tax rules typically treat that transfer as occurring at the deceased’s adjusted cost base, so no immediate capital gains tax arises at that time. Executors can, in some circumstances, elect to report capital gains on the deceased’s final tax return, but if that election wasn’t made, the accumulated gain effectively carries over to the surviving spouse. In your case, that means any built-up capital gains on the cottage likely transferred to you, which is important if you change ownership later.

Do you have to share an inherited cottage?

Legally, if the cottage passed to you by right of survivorship, you may not be required to transfer or add your stepchildren as owners. However, there can be a strong moral expectation to include them, and if you decide to transfer ownership to them, that transfer will usually be treated as a disposition for tax purposes and can trigger capital gains tax for you.

Tax implications when transferring ownership

If you gift part of the cottage to your stepchildren, Canadian tax law generally treats that transfer at fair market value. That means the capital gain is calculated using the fair market value at the time of transfer, even if the property is gifted for a nominal amount. An independent appraisal can be useful evidence of fair market value and is often advisable when ownership changes within a family, though it’s not strictly mandatory.

The capital gains tax bill could be significant if the cottage has been owned for many years. If you have the funds to pay the tax, that may be one route. If not, you’ll need to explore other options or structuring choices, ideally with professional advice.

Principal residence exemption and alternatives

One possible way to avoid an immediate capital gain is to designate the cottage as your principal residence for the years you owned it, which can reduce or eliminate the taxable gain on transfer. But using the principal residence exemption for the cottage has trade-offs: you might then be unable to claim that exemption later for your primary residence in the city, potentially creating a capital gains exposure on that property when you sell it or on your death. Also, if you already claimed a principal residence exemption on another property for overlapping years, you may be limited in claiming it again for the cottage.

Another path is to keep the cottage titled only in your name and arrange for it to pass to your stepchildren on your death through your will. That approach can defer taxation until a later date, but it may not satisfy stepchildren who expect an immediate ownership interest. Family relationships and expectations can make these choices particularly sensitive.

Practical steps and advice

Given the legal and tax complexity, it’s sensible to get professional guidance. A lawyer can confirm how the cottage was titled and whether joint ownership applied. An accountant or tax advisor can quantify any capital gains exposure and help evaluate whether using the principal residence exemption or another strategy makes sense for your overall tax situation.

Getting an appraisal is often a practical step when transferring property within a family, since it documents fair market value and supports the tax position. Even if it isn’t legally required, an appraisal can prevent disputes and clarify potential tax consequences before you make a transfer.

Finally, consider family dynamics alongside the tax and legal factors. Cottages often carry emotional value and can be a source of conflict, especially in blended families. Clear communication and professional advice can help you balance fairness, tax efficiency, and family relationships.

More about COTTAGES:

• Selling a cottage to a family member
• Can I sell my cottage tax-free?
• Reducing capital gains on the sale of a cottage
• Can I convince my in-laws to sell us their cottage?
• A portable cottage
• When to sell the family cottage
• Buy the cottage life for a fraction of the price
• Vacation properties: Where to buy now